Your Insurance Broker's Blog

A Fake Invoice, a Real Payment: Is Your Small Business Protected?

The logo is right. So is the supplier’s name. The amount even matches a recent order. In the email accompanying the invoice, there’s just one small update: the banking details have changed.

Your accounting manager processes the payment. A few days later, the supplier follows up: they’re still waiting for their money.

Somewhere along the way, a fraudster diverted the funds.

This scenario can affect a retail store, a construction company or a professional firm. To succeed, fraudsters exploit a very human instinct: trusting someone you already do business with.

Fraud That Blends into Everyday Business

Supplier impersonation fraud involves posing as a business partner to redirect a payment to a fraudulent account. The message may come from an address that looks almost identical to the original, or from a legitimate email account that has been compromised. The Canadian Anti-Fraud Centre identifies this scheme among the frauds targeting businesses.

Consider this fictional example. A small business is expecting a $12,000 invoice for equipment. An email arrives at just the right time, with a convincing invoice and new payment instructions. Eager to settle the account, the team sends the transfer.

The order is real. The amount is expected. But the bank account belongs to the fraudster.

This is a form of social engineering: manipulating someone into taking action because they believe they are responding to a legitimate request.

Warning Signs Worth Checking

A fraudulent invoice won’t necessarily contain spelling mistakes or look unprofessional. Some messages are highly convincing.

Still, certain details warrant a closer look:

  • A change in banking details communicated only by email.
  • An urgent request that pressures you to bypass normal procedures.
  • A new payee or an unusual payment destination.
  • An email address that differs slightly from the one on file.
  • Someone who insists on communicating exclusively in writing.

A well-written email is no guarantee of authenticity. And replying to the same message to ask for confirmation may simply put you back in touch with the fraudster.

Does Your Business Insurance Cover the Diverted Payment?

The answer depends on your policy’s coverage and the circumstances of the fraud.

In particular, it’s important to distinguish between a computer intrusion and a payment authorized by an employee who was deceived by false instructions. These situations may fall under different coverages.

Social engineering fraud coverage may be available through crime insurance or a policy endorsement. Intact Insurance, for example, offers coverage for losses resulting from a fraudster impersonating a business partner, client or employee to obtain a transfer.

It’s best to ask your broker a specific question: “If we voluntarily pay an invoice after receiving fraudulent banking details, does our policy provide coverage?”

Take the opportunity to review coverage limits, deductibles, exclusions and any required verification procedures. Having cyber insurance alone does not mean that this type of payment would be reimbursed.

Simple Habits That Make Life Harder for Fraudsters

The most useful habit is to confirm any banking change by phone, using a number you already know, rather than the one provided in the message. The RCMP recommends this independent verification when payment information is being changed.

Establish a clear procedure for new payees and large payments, too. A second approval can help, provided it includes an actual verification.

Make sure everyone involved understands the risks: management, accounting, administrative staff and employees covering for colleagues. The procedure should stay the same even when the boss is away or a supplier seems impatient.

Enable multifactor authentication on email accounts as well. It helps protect account access, while payment checks help detect deceptive requests.

The Transfer Has Been Sent: What Now?

Contact your financial institution immediately to report the fraud and ask whether the transfer can be stopped or the funds recovered. Acting quickly may help, but recovery is not guaranteed.

Notify your broker or insurer promptly as well. Keep the original emails, invoices, banking instructions and proof of payment. If an email account may have been compromised, involve your IT specialist.

Finally, report the incident to the police and the Canadian Anti-Fraud Centre, which recommends reporting fraud targeting businesses.

A Check Before Your Next Payment

A fake invoice can look just like the ones you pay every week. That’s exactly what makes it dangerous.

At Assurances Groupe Vézina, your broker can help you review your business’s protection against fraud and cyber risks. A few questions today could save you an unpleasant surprise when you send your next transfer.